Compare Church Website Options: Costs, Features, and Everyday Fit

By Chapel Desk · November 12, 2026 · 6 min read

Church homepage previews displayed side by side on a meeting-room monitor.

The best church website choice is the one your volunteers can maintain and your church can afford beyond the first year. Start by deciding whether you need a public website alone, a website with communication tools, or a wider system for church administration.

For an initial shortlist, consider Tithely for its published website-only price, Nucleus for website-connected signups and communication, The Church Co for assisted setup, and Subsplash for a package that includes websites, apps, and media. These are suggested fits based on the providers' published offerings, not rankings from hands-on testing. The comparison below links to the supporting product pages.

Compare the published offers

Use this table to choose which demonstrations to request. It compares specific offers rather than assuming every provider includes the same features.

Church website services and questions to ask
ServicePublished price or pricing approachSuggested fitAsk before subscribing
TithelyWebsite advertised at $19 per month; All Access at $119 per monthA church comparing a website subscription with a broader software packageWhich tools require All Access rather than the website subscription?
NucleusEssential $65, Standard $99, Complete $199 per monthA team wanting website-connected signups, visitor follow-up, and communicationWhich plan covers your sermon library, newsletters, and giving needs?
The Church CoSubscription and setup are separate choices; Simple setup is free with a yearly subscriptionA church wanting help preparing its initial siteWhat is the subscription total, setup scope, and revision allowance?
SubsplashSubsplash One pricing depends on church size and usageA church evaluating websites alongside apps, streaming, and media hostingWhat is the written price for your actual size and intended usage?

Sources: Tithely pricing, Nucleus pricing, The Church Co pricing, and Subsplash pricing.

What each option offers

Tithely: compare website-only and bundled tools

Tithely advertises its website service at $19 per month. Its website product page lists mobile-optimized templates, live editing, a sermon library, an events calendar, and hosting. Its separate All Access offer is listed at $119 per month and includes additional church-management and communication tools. See the website features and plan comparison.

This makes it worth reviewing when you want to price a website separately before considering a larger package. During the demonstration, ask the volunteer who will maintain the site to update a service time and publish an event. Then request a written list of what the selected subscription includes.

Nucleus: connect website visits with follow-up

Nucleus lists Essential at $65 per month, including its website tools, signup forms, prayer requests, and visitor follow-up. Standard, listed at $99 per month, adds a sermon library and communication tools. Complete is listed at $199 per month and adds Giving and Media. Its website tools include hosting, SSL, custom-domain connection, and page-specific team access. These details appear on the Nucleus pricing page.

Consider this option if your evaluation centers on what happens after someone clicks a signup button. Ask to follow a sample submission from the public website through to the person responsible for replying. Also ask which existing mailing or registration tasks you would keep elsewhere.

The Church Co: define the setup work

The Church Co separates the subscription decision from the setup package. Its pricing page lists Simple setup as free with a yearly subscription, covering up to nine pages with no revision cycle. Paid setup options list larger page allowances and revision cycles. The same page says churches can build the site themselves. Review the setup packages before comparing quotes.

This is worth considering when the initial build is the work your team wants help with. Prepare a page inventory before requesting a proposal. Ask which photographs, documents, and existing pages will be moved, what you must supply, and how later updates will be handled.

Subsplash: evaluate the wider package

Subsplash One lists websites, media hosting, custom mobile and TV apps, live streaming, online giving, people management, and other church tools. Its pricing page says the package price depends on church size and usage rather than publishing a single subscription amount. See the Subsplash package details.

Consider a demonstration if your buying decision includes media distribution or an app as well as a website. Bring a list of the tools you already use and ask the representative to identify which would remain. Request a written quote based on your intended use, not a general overview of everything available.

Decide what you are actually replacing

Before opening trials, write down your current tasks. Separate public information from administrative work so that your comparison does not become a contest over the longest feature list.

  1. List public website tasks: service times, directions, events, announcements, documents, and contact requests.
  2. List communication tasks: event reminders, newsletters, visitor replies, and member messages.
  3. List administrative tasks: household records, giving records, expenses, statements, and member access.
  4. Mark each task as keep, replace, or not needed.
  5. Ask each provider to show the tasks marked replace on the plan you would actually purchase.

If your existing records and giving arrangements work well, ask for a website-focused proposal first. If you want to consolidate several tasks, request a second proposal that shows exactly which subscriptions and manual steps could be replaced. Do not assume that a donation button also supplies the internal finance workflow you want; ask for that workflow to be demonstrated.

Run the same practical test with each finalist

Give your two finalists the same short assignment. Use sample information rather than uploading real member records during an initial demonstration.

  • Change a service time and check the result on a phone.
  • Add an event with a location and contact person.
  • Upload a bulletin or other public document.
  • Submit a contact form and follow the response process.
  • Give a second volunteer appropriate editing access.
  • Find the support instructions for a task you have not tried before.

Ask your regular volunteer to operate the controls rather than only watching a salesperson. Record where help was needed, what remained unclear, and whether the result met your requirements. This is an evaluation exercise, not a race: aim to understand the work before committing to it.

Compare the full cost and handover plan

Request a first-year total and a renewal-year total. Include the subscription, any assisted setup, domain renewal, separate email hosting, optional tools, and payment-processing charges where relevant. Ask providers to distinguish required charges from optional services.

Also request a written handover plan. Who will control the domain account? Who will approve the new site? What happens to existing page addresses? How will office email be protected during the change? What can be exported if the church later leaves?

Avoid choosing on the opening subscription price alone. Give your committee the total cost alongside the tasks covered and the work your volunteers will still do.

Before the church approves a subscription

  • Two volunteers have tried the ordinary editing tasks.
  • The proposed plan covers the agreed requirements.
  • Setup responsibilities and revision allowances are written down.
  • The first-year and renewal costs are clear.
  • Trial conversion and cancellation terms have been reviewed.
  • Domain access and office email responsibilities are assigned.
  • Member information will not be used in public demonstrations.
  • A named person will review the site before launch.

Choose the option that passes these checks and fits your actual workload. A useful purchasing decision should explain not just why the website looks suitable, but who will keep it current and what the church is agreeing to pay.

Doing this in Chapel Desk

Chapel Desk is a fifth option to consider if you want church management software with your website included, bringing website updates, household records, event reminder emails, and finance tools into one system, subject to the selected plan. It offers three website themes and your own domain, but does not currently offer recurring giving or SMS. Review the current plan inclusions before starting its seven-day trial, which requires a card and converts automatically unless canceled.

Sources

← All guides